« A few things I learned at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratories: | Main | So your friend asks...Do you think we'll ever talk to aliens? »

Science Highlight: Scientific Speculation about the Solar System

Say that five times fast.

Attendees at the Extreme Solar Systems II conference, held from September 11-17 at the extreme Grand Teton National Park, discussed the ultimate fate of Earth and, by implication, the ultimate fates of rocky inner planets across the universe.

In astronomy, we can do two things

  1. Observe the systems that we can observe and, from those observations, draw conclusions about similar systems and draw conclusions about what these systems used to be like and what they will be like the future. The classic analogy goes a little something like, "Imagine that an alien came to Earth" (not going to happen, but I'll continue) "and took pictures of humans and then took them back to Planet X. They would be able to classify humans into a few groups: babies, teenagers, adults, and old people. They might ask, 'Are these separate species, or different stages of the same animal? If the same animal, does the animal grow shorter as it ages, or taller?' etc. Astronomers do the same thing with populations of stars. Since, even over many lifetimes, we're really only getting a snapshot of an object's whole lifetime, we can't observe how that life progresses. We have only the images we take back to our home planet; we must connect the dots between them ourselves. So we try to look at old and young (and more massive and less massive, etc.) systems of the same type, to discover what they look like at different stages of their lives, and how they move between these stages.
  2. Take the information we know about a system--based on our observations of existing systems--and the physical laws (E=McSquared, F=ma) to which the system is subject and use the combination to make a simulation. A simulation shows all the in-between times--it provides the line between the dots. It can also provide a line beyond the dots, to see how systems will look in the distant future, or a line behind the dots, to show the baby system.
If a simulation doesn't fit with observations, that's the simulation's problem.
If observations don't fit with a simulation, that's the simulation's problem. Astronomers need both types of data.

At this Extreme Solar Systems conference, scientists discussed what will become of Earth when the Sun enters different stages of its development: the red giant and, later, the white dwarf phases.

I found this hilarious comic.
You can read Science's summary of Earth's potential fates (here), but the one that the literarian in me likes the best is the most circular: if Earth isn't subsumed by the enlarged red giant Sun, it will likely be ripped into pieces, either by tidal forces or collision with Mars.

These pieces, however, could ultimately become part of a disk of rocky material orbiting the white dwarf Sun. This rocky material could, like the material in the protoplanetary disk that formed our current solar system, form new rocky planets.

The progression is thus A-->B-->A(ish)-->B(ish): It's like slant rhyme for the universe.

Schilling, Govert (16 Sept 2011), "Earth's Ultimate Destruction--and Possible Reincarnation," ScienceNow.

EmailEmail Article to Friend

References (10)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    Response: index service
    Great Web-site, Stick to the fantastic job. Thanks for your time!
  • Response
    Response: breast
  • Response
    It is your own responsibility to get higher education seriously because it is the matter of your own future and no doubt you want a happy, healthy and successful future. So you should take serious steps about your professional and higher education in your educational time and never ignore this fact. ...
  • Response
  • Response
    Response: website
  • Response
    Response: wintel pro w8
    wintel pro w8
  • Response
    Response: Baby Care Tips
  • Response
    Response: 5
  • Response
  • Response

Reader Comments (3)


February 4, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAnonymous

Such a speculation might occur especially if the observation is accurate. I hope we can cope with the changes if ever the sun enters different stages of its development.
http://www.solarpanelsinfo.co.uk/" rel="nofollow">solar energy

February 5, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterFrank Hendon

funny comic

March 24, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAnonymous

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>